10 Best Rated Extra Firm Mattresses – In-Depth Reviews

B ack pain can appear as a consequence of an improper position while resting, and, in most cases, this has to do with the mattress in use. While soft or medium models may seem more appealing, if you’ve already started experiencing pain in your lumbar or neck area, it’s time to move up to a firm mattress.

Being made of superior materials, these models will make you forget about poor sleep or back pain. Compare them, read their reviews, and pick the one you like the most.

Top 10 Extra Firm Mattresses Compared

Photo	Product Name	Sizes Available	Construction	Comfort Layer	Support Layer	Profile	Cover	Warranty	Price
Best Overall	1. Beautyrest Platinum Badger	California King	Innerspring & Foam	Comfort Foam	Memory Foam	12.5″		10-year	Check Price
Our Choice	2. Zinus Performance Plus	Twin , Full , Queen , King	Innerspring & foam	1.5″ comfort foam; 2.5″ high-density foam support	17.5″ layer of individually wrapped coils	12”		10-year	Check Price
	3. Modway Aveline 10-Inch	Narrow Twin , Twin , Full , Queen , King , California King	Foam	Ventilated Gel-Infused Foam	Responsive Base Foam	10”		10-year	Check Price
Best Memory Foam	4. Best Price Mattress 10-Inch	Twin , Twin XL , Full , Queen , King , Short Queen , California King	Foam	2″ pressure relief foam; 3″ memory foam	5″ high-density base foam	10”		10-year	Check Price
Best for Allergies	5. Ashley 8-Inch Innerspring	Twin , Full , Queen , King	Innerspring & foam	High-density pad; 2″ high-density quilt foam	Innerspring coils	8”		5-year	Check Price
Best for Back Pain	6. Signature Sleep Contour	Twin , Full , Queen , King	Innerspring & foam	1.6″ high-density foam (top and bottom)	7″ independently encased coils	8”		1-year	Check Price
Best for the Money	7. Linenspa 5-Inch	Twin , Twin XL , Full , Full XL , Queen , King , California King	Foam	1″ gel memory foam	4″ high-density base foam	5”		10-year	Check Price
	8. LUCID 5 Inch Gel Memory Foam Mattress	King	Foam	1″ Soft, Ventilated Cooling Layer	4″ Supportive Base Foam	5”		10-year	Check Price
	9. Serta iComfort Blue 300	Twin , Twin XL , Full , Queen , King , California King	Innerspring & Foam	Gel Memory Foam	Ultimate Edge Foam Core	11.25		10-year	Check Price
	10. Allassea Gold Perfect Nite	, Queen	Innerspring & Foam	Swirl Gel Memory Foam	High Density Memory Foam & Soring Pocket Coils	12		10-year	Check Price

1. Beautyrest Platinum Badger

Check Price at Amazon

This model ranked first for its luxurious but also hard-wearing construction. It successfully combines the memory foam with distinctly-enfolded coils, which are better shock-absorbers and prevent sinking. With a profile height of 13” and no less than 5 dimensions to choose from, it is a wonderful ally in eliminating back pains and encouraging profound sleep.

You won’t see many beds as innovative as this one. The top stratum involves density foam that offers a relaxing feel and an imbued stratum of fibers that dispel the heat and conserve the correct sleeping temperature.

The separately-wrapped coil technology does a great job in promoting point tension relief and assuring no motion transfer. Additionally, the Air Cool memory foam stratum stimulates airflow and delivers the necessary edge support.

Another great trait is the compatibility with the SmartMotion base which allows you to observe your sleep through the Sleeptracker app. Furthermore, a 10-year service contract is offered, so if you undergo any difficulties with this model, you can get in contact with the company and it fixed without paying any extra money.

---

2. Zinus Performance Plus

Check Price at Amazon

It offers exceptional firmness without affecting the body’s ability to relax, and this is conceivable due to the well-thought arrangement of strata. It has a 12” profile, functioning as a thick layer between you and the bedframe, thus promising that you don’t feel sore when you wake up or develop long-term back pains. Moreover, the design is just superb, boosting cleanness and freshness.

It comes with a 0.5” Celliant cover that protects it and makes it more hard-wearing. As for the composition, it is made of 1.5” comfort foam and 2.5” high-density foam that outlines the line of your body and aids lessen stress points.

The bottom layer contains hundreds of iCoil separately-wrapped springs that offer first-class support and motion separation. Consequently, you will be able to experience an uninterrupted sleep every night. For more convenience, this model comes with a 10-year service contract and a CertiPUR certification.

---

3. Modway Aveline 10-Inch

Check Price at Amazon

Offering firm support while adjusting to your body, this model will help you dispense with back pain and line up the spine. It is formed of 2 strata of foam protected by a supple textile.

The support stratum contains 7” of responsive base foam while the top stratum is made of 3” of gel-filled memory foam that easily conforms to you. It is well aired, so it doesn’t retain heat, keeping you cool and relaxed. The foam doesn’t contain toxic chemicals, being indorsed by CertiPUR-US. The covering is a diamond-patterned stretch knit that can be detached for the weekly wash.

It comes in a compact box and it needs one day to fully decompress. It is obtainable in more sizes and you can opt for different depths – 6”, 8”, or 10”. It is backed by a 10-year service assurance.

---

4. Best Price Mattress 10-Inch

Check Price at Amazon

A very well-liked choice to go with is this model made by Best Price. It is completely made of memory foam, yet it is firm enough to help you get rid of back pain after only several nights.
The model selected by us is 10-inch thick and comes in 6 sizes but you can also opt for a 6”, 8”, or 12” profile.

The 10-inch model comprises 3 strata of foam that help lessen motion transfer and reduces stress points. It is protected by a Poly-Jacquard cover that is highly comfortable. A proof that it is safe to use is the fact that it comes with a CertiPUR accreditation – the foam used hasn’t been treated with chemical substances.

Plus, it is hard-wearing, so you can be sure it is a long-term investment. Moreover, it comes with a 10-year service contract.

---

5. Ashley 8-Inch Innerspring

Check Price at Amazon

This model was specially created to offer a relaxing sleep as it is made of superior fabrics. It is obtainable in numerous sizes and it has a profile height of 8”.
The support stratum is made of 13-gauge distinctively-wrapped coils that take the outline of your body. The comfort strata are comprised of a firming pad and 2” quilt foam that add a lush sensation.

All the textiles are hypoallergenic, it is impervious to mold and dust mites. This makes it ideal for individuals with allergies. Moreover, no upkeep is required, as it manages to remain clean and dust-free.

It comes in a box and it is enfolded in plastic. To unroll it, just remove the wrap and let it expand. It needs only several minutes to fully expand. While it is true that it may emit a rather unpleasant smell at the beginning, you shouldn’t worry as it won’t take long until it disappears completely.

---

6. Signature Sleep Contour

Check Price at Amazon

Experience a relaxing sleep with this innovative model. It is obtainable in 4 sizes and 2 height options: 8” and 10”. The 8” model is a fusion made of memory foam and distinctly encased coils.

This model is reversible, so you can reverse and rotate it regularly to extend its durability. The middle stratum is made of 7” of 15 gauge distinctly coated coils for greater support and no motion transfer. Then, on both sides, it features multiple strata that provide a superior level of comfort.

The foam used for constructing it is CertiPUR-US approved, which means it doesn’t contain ozone depletes, lead, mercury, or heavy metals. Moreover, it has no PBDEs, TDCPP, or TCEP flame retardants. For protecting indoor air quality, it has low VOC emanations.

It comes in a box that protects it during transport. Once unboxed, you have to wait for up to 72 hours to completely expand. Plus, the product is warranted for 10 years so you will be covered in case you discover any manufacturing flaw.

---

7. Linenspa 5-Inch

Check Price at Amazon

It features a low profile – 5 inches – which makes it a nice option for your kid’s bedroom. Also, it is an outstanding option for bunk or trundle beds. In terms of expediency, it is very generous as you can opt for 7 sizes. It is very lightweight and easy to handle.

Its expediency comes from the fact that it is made completely of foam without losing its firmness. Thus, it is easy to manipulate but the diverse foam strata guarantee that the body lays in a healthy position overnight and diminishes the likelihood of muscular pain appearing in the morning. Although it has a profile of only 5”, the premium foam inside it ensures that your little one will rest without feeling the bed structure. Furthermore, as the upper stratum is filled with gel, the body doesn’t get hot at night and, thus, sleep is unaffected.

As an added plus, it is covered by a 10-year service contract. It comes as a roll, so it’s recommended to leave it at least 24 hours to gain its initial shape.

---

8. LUCID 5 Inch Gel Memory Foam Mattress

Check Price at Amazon

Specially created to improve your sleep and get you rid of back pain, this model may be exactly what you’ve been looking for. It has a low profile as it is only 5 inches tall, so it is great for your kid’s bed or other low profile platform bed.

While adults may find it uncomfortable to sleep on this low-profile model when placed directly on the bed structure, most children and teens will find it incredibly comforting. Moreover, if the bed has a trundle design, the low profile will help you store it under the bed without difficulties.
To protect the product from allergens and bed bugs, it comes with a thin cover made of hypoallergenic materials.

It is obtainable in manifold sizes to complement your bed frame, and it is warranted for 10 years. Thus, if any flaw may prevent it from functioning as described in this period, it can be addressed and solved by the company with no additional expenses on your part.

---

9. Serta iComfort Blue 300

Check Price at Amazon

This is the firmest model made by Serta, and it is the elevated version of the Blue 100 medium firm model. It is ideal for all those who want a firm bed to support their body but also to enjoy the gains of the memory foam feel. The model is carefully crafted and comes with some nice features that are meant to improve your sleep.

iComfort Blue 300 comes in several sizes to match your needs. Its profile has a height of 11.5 inches in all sizes. It is made of manifold strata of memory foam and comprises a nice stretch cover that is silky and allows it to follow your body’s outline. Moreover, the top cover doesn’t wear out very easily.

Comfort layer construction:

• TempActiv gel memory foam – it is imbued with gel beads and helps capture the excess heat from your body and dissipate it.
• EverCool Fuze memory foam – it is highly resistant to temperature variations.
• Serta support foam – for added steadiness and comfort.
• Deep Reaction memory foam – helps provide a firm feel.

Support layer construction:

Ultimate edge foam core – it is made of a support core that provides great back support and isolates motion transfer and edge foam encasement that averts collapsing when sitting on the edge.

This model comes with a CertiPUR-US accreditation. This denotes that the poly foam used in the production process has been tested to meet the standards of the accreditation program. Also, the Serta iComfort line has been awarded by the Consumer’s Digest with the Best Buy certificate for 6 consecutive years.

---

10. Allassea Gold Perfect Nite

Check Price at Amazon

Another great selection to go with is Allassea Gold Perfect Nite. You will love its design, as well as the well-made construction and comfortable support. It has a profile height of 12” and 4 dimensions to choose from.

For better protection during transportation, it is carefully wrapped in plastic and then packed in a highly-resistant carton.

This model is a fusion one, so it features both memory foam and separated wrapped coils. It comes with a stylish covering that compliments any bedroom decor while protecting the bed’s exterior. The swirl gel memory foam, which is the top stratum, is very comfortable and preserves the ideal body temperature while adjusting to your body.

Furthermore, the spring pocket coils do a great job in decreasing tension on the body. Moreover, the bed is compatible with all bed frames.

---

Product Ratings

When we rated the products, we took into consideration the most important aspects related to a mattress. Consequently, we ranked our models according to the profile height, sizes available, construction, and so on. In this way, we were able to objectively present you with the best model available. Remember that the quality of your sleep has great significance for a healthy life.

• Profile height: the profile height represents the depth of a mattress. Rendering to this criterion, the models are classified as follows:
  – Low profile: between 2” and 5”;
  – Thin: between 5” and 8”;
  – Standard: between 8” and 12”;
  – Medium-to-thick: between 12” and 20”;
  – Very thick: above 20”.

  The most widespread types are the standard ones, being simultaneously more expensive than thin beds. This is mainly because they are made of multiple layers that deliver the necessary support during the night. Very thick models are very expensive and less common and they are usually found in traditional bedroom decor.

• Sizes available: each model comes in various sizes to match your frame size. From this point of view, the most versatile ones are those available in more sizes.

• Layers: like most models with a standard thickness, our selections are made of a comfort stratum and a support stratum. While the comfort stratum is only a few inches thick, the core or support layer is much thicker. The materials used in producing them are numerous and they differ from one model to another. If we take a closer look at our models, all of them feature a comfort layer made of foam. Undeniably, there are diverse technologies of foam that promise exceptional support and from our point of view, these models won’t disappoint you. The support strata may be made of foam, inner springs, coils, etc. According to specialists pocketed coils are better than inner springs as they are individually pocketed in a fabric sleeve. This technology provides superior support and negligible motion transfer.
• Cover: its purpose is to protect the product against wear and dirt. With time the cover may deteriorate but the interior will remain the same. Most of the models selected by us come with a beautifully designed cover that not only makes them more stylish but also increases their longevity.
• Warranty: the standard service contract is 10 years. During this period, if there are any defects in workmanship and materials, the product will be either replaced or repaired. A long warranty offers you peace of mind and for this reason, we selected only models with good warranties.

---

Health Benefits of Sleeping on a Firm Mattress

In the past, firm models were considered rather uncomfortable due to the hard construction. Yet, many people were willing to sacrifice comfort for support. Fortunately, in the present times, most firm models are ingeniously made to offers you not only firm support but also a comfortable sleep.

• Prevents and alleviates back pain: since firm support keeps your spine in the right position, you will no longer suffer from back pains. You can also prevent back problems just by sleeping on a hard mattress.
• Promotes a deep rest: how many times did you wake up feeling tired? In most cases, sleeping on a bad mattress can lead to interrupted sleep, which in time can affect your health. A firm bed will offer you a deep rest through the night, feeling much more energized in the morning.
• Even weight dispersal: due to the lack of support, soft mattresses can make your body sag in one direction, leading to misalignment in the muscle and joints. A hard bed will do the opposite, as it promotes even weight dissemination.

---

Conclusion

In conclusion, we believe that a firm mattress offers excellent support to all those who agonize over back pains. Additionally, it is expressly designed to promote a comfortable sleep while helping preserve proper spine placement.

To get the perfect match, keep an eye on dimensions, materials, and features, and don’t hesitate to revisit 5 of the best models in this top:

Best Overall: Beautyrest Platinum Badger

An opulent model that guarantees restful nights and mornings that are filled with energy. Based on an innerspring and foam support technology, it doesn’t sink, but supports the body, offering a good posture that will prevent back pain. Moreover, your sleep won’t get affected, not even in the summer, as the top stratum is imbued with Tencel, which helps keep the body cool and comfortable. Last but not least, it comes with a 10-year service contract, which guarantees that the manufacturer will take care of any damage that may appear in this period as an effect of possible manufacturing faults.

Editor’s Choice: Zinus Performance Plus

CertiPUR-US approved, this is the best you can choose in terms of back support. The bottom layer is made of separately enfolded coils, expressly designed to maintain its shape, no matter the user’s weight. This layer is then topped with a thick comfort layer, which is made of foam and covered in luxurious Jacquard fabric, offering the maximum comfort for peaceful nights. It comes in 3 sizes and is easy to assemble. Moreover, it is covered by a super generous 10-year service contract so you can put your mind at rest and enjoy the comfy nights.

Best Memory Foam Extra Firm Mattress: Best Price Mattress 10-Inch

It will offer you the best sleep you could dream about, as it is built of multiple layers of foam, therefore offers an even resting surface with no tension points. The comfort is increased by the premium-quality Jacquard cover, specially created to allow your skin to breathe. It is certified for safety and reliability by CertiPUR and is backed by an excellent 10-year service contract. Additionally, the company provides it in 7 dimensions to make sure that you will get exactly what you need.

Best Extra Firm Mattress for the Money: Linenspa 5-Inch

Highly versatile, this model comes in no less than 7 sizes, so you will be able to find a perfect match for your queen or king-size bed, for the tween bed in your kid’s room, and even for a California King bed. It comes rolled and compacted in a box, so one person can easily maneuver and install it. Plus, the benefits don’t stop here, as it costs less than many other models but offers exceptional quality, great back support, and a generous 10-year service contract.

Best Extra Firm Mattress for Back Pain: Signature Sleep Contour

Built of superior-quality foam and long-lasting coils, this model will provide you with exceptional support and comfort without endangering your health, as it doesn’t contain lead, mercury, or heavy metals that are often found in cheaper models. The cover is made of airy fabric to keep you cool even during the summer. Besides that, it is easy to set and can be flipped, therefore it will maintain its shape for a very long time.

Best Extra Firm Mattress for Allergies: Ashley 8-Inch

Not only that it offers premium support for your back due to the foam and innerspring coil system but it is thought to protect you against pollen, dust mites or pet dander that tend to gather in regular mattresses. It is built only of hypoallergenic fabrics, so it is a great choice for kid rooms or for users with sensitive skin. Furthermore, it is compatible with all types of bed frames, whether you own a traditional, platform, box spring, or adjustable bed. You can even place it on the floor and sleep like a baby.